Canon 188.4 and Clerical State - 12 reasons why kurgan is wrong



The Council of Trent's "anathema" statements show us that canon 188.4 has NOTHING to do with a loss of clerical state. Once a priest, always a priest. Kurgan has avoided two simple yes/no questions that I have repeatedly asked him that prove this. So, to prove my position beyond the shadow of a doubt, I will add ten more questions to those for the kurgan to answer:


YES or NO?


1 - Upon ordination, is a character imprinted on the priest/Bishop?

2 - Can an ordained priest ever become a layman?

3 - Is ordination a true sacrament, instituted by Jesus Christ Himself?

4 - is ordination just a human invention, with no divine properties?

5 - Is the Holy Spirit given to the Bishop at ordination?

6 - When the bishop says to a priest during ordination, “Receive the Holy Spirit”, does the priest actually receive the Holy Spirit?

7 - Can sacred ordination ever be invalidated?

8 - Are priests whose lives have been debased by crime still within the Church?

9 - Does a bishop or priest whose life has been debased by crime lose their sacramental power?

10 - Can excommunicated Bishops validly ordain other bishops and priests?

11 - Can a laicized priest still hear a sacramental confession in an emergency, and confer other sacraments validly?

12 - Can a priest ever resign from the priesthood?


The answers of the Magisterium of the Catholic Church are as follows:


1 - YES

2 - NO

3 - YES

4 - NO

5 - YES

6 - YES

7 - NO

8 - YES

9 - NO

10 - YES

11 - YES

12 - NO


So, what are your answers kurgan? Are you ready to admit that a priest can never lose the clerical state, and always has the ability to validly (but not licitly) perform the sacraments? 

I expect nothing but silence or name calling. You are defeated.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Kurgan promotes Lust and Masturbation

Image
The Kurgan is now promoting lust and masturbation as a path to martial bliss.  To set the table, let's take a look at the official Catholic definitions of "Lust" and "Mastubation" LUST - A disordered desire for or inordinate enjoyment of sexual pleasure. Sexual pleasure is morally disordered when sought for itself, isolated from its procreative and unitive purposes. Source - Catechism of the Catholic Church 1992 - #2351 MASTURBATION - The deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. Masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action. The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to it's purpose. Source - CCC - #2351 And we also see by the sin of Onan, who God slew, God does not approve of contraception, which Onan was guilty of by "pulling out" and wasting his seed on the ground. Source - https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/the-s...
Read more

Pope Francis says that all religions lead to God, and he is absolutely correct.

Image
Before all of you "trad" and "faithful" christians or catholics get your shorts in a bunch and start in with the rash judgement, let's take a deep breath..... Breath in....... Hold,,,,,, Breath out.        Breath in........Hold........Breath out...... OK. Now that we have relaxed our muscles and a we have a brain full of oxygen, let's discuss. The article is here: https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/breaking-pope-francis-every-religion-is-a-way-to-arrive-at-god/ Now, let's break down the article, and analyze what is said and the context in which it was said. " Pope Francis today told young people of different faiths that “every religion is a way to arrive at God.” Addressing an inter-religious meeting of young people in Singapore just before departing for his return flight to Rome, Pope Francis turned to one of the central themes of his pontificate – inter-religious dialogue." So far, so good. The Pope is speaking to a group of young people of di...
Read more

Three Marriages, No Annulments — The Domestic Contradiction of The Kurgan

“Let marriage be held in honor among all, and let the marriage bed be undefiled.” — Hebrews 13:4 The Kurgan never misses a chance to attack others for their failings, especially in matters of faith. He’s the first to declare someone “not a real Catholic,” denounce “fake clergy,” or assign people to the flames for liturgical imperfection. But when it comes to his own life , a strange silence takes hold. Or worse—an open contradiction. In his latest blog post, “The Cowards,” he casually admits: “I made plenty of errors too. Twice divorced and many women in between. BUT… I am now happily married with a sixth kid on the way.” The problem? He has never mentioned a single annulment . And as far as anyone can tell, he doesn’t recognize any ecclesiastical authority capable of granting one. After all, in his view, the Church has been “fake” since 1958. Which means this supposed champion of tradition and canon law is—by his own admission— on his third marriage, with no canonical process, n...
Read more