Canon 188.4 and Clerical State - 12 reasons why kurgan is wrong



The Council of Trent's "anathema" statements show us that canon 188.4 has NOTHING to do with a loss of clerical state. Once a priest, always a priest. Kurgan has avoided two simple yes/no questions that I have repeatedly asked him that prove this. So, to prove my position beyond the shadow of a doubt, I will add ten more questions to those for the kurgan to answer:


YES or NO?


1 - Upon ordination, is a character imprinted on the priest/Bishop?

2 - Can an ordained priest ever become a layman?

3 - Is ordination a true sacrament, instituted by Jesus Christ Himself?

4 - is ordination just a human invention, with no divine properties?

5 - Is the Holy Spirit given to the Bishop at ordination?

6 - When the bishop says to a priest during ordination, “Receive the Holy Spirit”, does the priest actually receive the Holy Spirit?

7 - Can sacred ordination ever be invalidated?

8 - Are priests whose lives have been debased by crime still within the Church?

9 - Does a bishop or priest whose life has been debased by crime lose their sacramental power?

10 - Can excommunicated Bishops validly ordain other bishops and priests?

11 - Can a laicized priest still hear a sacramental confession in an emergency, and confer other sacraments validly?

12 - Can a priest ever resign from the priesthood?


The answers of the Magisterium of the Catholic Church are as follows:


1 - YES

2 - NO

3 - YES

4 - NO

5 - YES

6 - YES

7 - NO

8 - YES

9 - NO

10 - YES

11 - YES

12 - NO


So, what are your answers kurgan? Are you ready to admit that a priest can never lose the clerical state, and always has the ability to validly (but not licitly) perform the sacraments? 

I expect nothing but silence or name calling. You are defeated.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

When You're Banned but not Answered — The Coward Behind the Curtain

Image
For all his talk of battle, blood, and bravery, The Kurgan once again proved that his bark is far louder than his bite. He recently published a post titled "Don’t Wrestle With Pigs," where he mocked those who dare to challenge him—calling them emotional, dishonest, even unteachable. The irony? I had posted a short, direct comment—free of insult, grounded in Catholic teaching, and pointing out the contradiction of a self-proclaimed defender of Catholicism who refuses to account for his own three marriages and lack of annulments. Rather than respond like a man, The Kurgan pulled the same cowardly move he’s used for years: silence the critic, ban the question, and hope his followers never notice the curtain being pulled back. 🧱 The Comment That Exposed the Hypocrisy Here’s the actual comment I posted on his Substack—the one he refused to answer, and for which I was banned: What was so threatening about this question? It wasn’t vulgar. It wasn’t personal. It simply asked the ...
Read more

The Gospel of the Toothpaste Cap: Kurgan’s Neuroscience of Bitterness

Every once in a while, The Kurgan attempts to solve all of human nature in one post. In his latest, titled “Implications of the theory of dual brain processing on relations between the sexes” , he claims to have discovered the root cause of most modern conflict between men and women: women are biologically incapable of logic, men are too logical to be understood, and all of this proves… something. It's hard to tell. The irony? For a man claiming left-brain supremacy, the post is a disorganized torrent of emotional reflections, failed marriages, and forgotten toothpaste caps. What follows isn’t science, and it certainly isn’t theology. It’s autobiography disguised as theory. 🧠 A “Theory” With No Author, No Structure, No Proof The essay is built on something he calls the “Dual Brain Processing Theory,” which he attributes to someone named “Gaius Baltar” — yes, like the villain from Battlestar Galactica . He gives no citations, no publication, and no scientific sourcing. He si...
Read more

Where Is the Love, Kurgan?

" This is how all will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another." — John 13: 35 I couldn’t help but notice something today as I reflected on the Gospel. And I couldn’t help but think of The Kurgan . Because for all his talk about being the last real Catholic on Earth, one thing is shockingly absent from everything he writes, says, or posts: Love . Scroll through his Substack, his blog, or his rants on Social Galactic, and try to find one post that radiates love, joy, hope, or genuine concern for another human soul. You won’t find it. What you will find is: Finger- pointing Mocking insults Sarcastic tirades Uncharitable speculation Endless condemnation Character assassination Self- congratulation It’s the digital equivalent of standing in the temple, beating his chest, and thanking God that he is not like the rest of us sinners. But where is the love for one another ? Where is the mercy ? Where is the invitation to hope ? Wher...
Read more